CAFM-Blog.de | The HOAI is Not the Monster Under the Bed – Why We're Having the Wrong Debates About Construction

The HOAI is Not the Monster Under the Bed – Why We're Having the Wrong Debates About Construction

When construction projects stall, costs skyrocket, and nerves fray, the culprit is usually found quickly: the Fee Structure for Architects and Engineers (HOAI). It's considered a dusty relic, a bureaucratic hindrance, and an enemy of all innovation. But anyone who knows from their own experience in project and facility management how things really work on German construction sites and in planning offices (okay, caught you) comes to a different conclusion: We're mistaking the thermometer for the illness.

Oh yes, and what's the blog about today? About the problems in the planning industry, the pitfalls of existing buildings, and the question of why abolishing the HOAI wouldn't save us – but only a smart reform would.

When I read debates about the HOAI, I regularly feel like I'm witnessing a favorite German pastime: You put a complex system in a corner, point at it with a serious expression, and exclaim: "There! That's the fault!" And then it stands there, the "HOAI", the Fee Structure for Architects and Engineers, primped like a management veteran on a company outing, and is suddenly supposed to be responsible for everything. It's allegedly to blame for slow projects, high construction costs, too much bureaucracy, lack of innovation, and probably also for the chronically clogged coffee machine in the construction office. But it's not that simple. The HOAI needs reform in some areas and is outdated, but it is indeed not the ultimate villain of planning and construction.

My impression after years in practice, juggling CAFM systems, technical building equipment, and countless project meetings: Anyone who wants to abolish the HOAI to reduce bureaucracy is just treating the symptoms. The regulation describes services, structures fees, and often serves as contractual orientation. But the real problems lie much deeper. They lurk in excessively long approval processes, sprawling procurement procedures, overly complex technical regulations, completely inadequately addressed existing building measures, and a culture that still surprisingly likes to treat intellectual planning work as a secondary matter. The dispute over the HOAI is therefore not necessarily wrong, but completely misdirected. People are discussing the visible form margin ("Mr. Meier, best to send it by fax!") while the pipes in the engine room have long since burst.

The Comfortable Fallacy of Bureaucracy Reduction

In complex systems, discussions almost never take place where the greatest friction lies, but rather where one can most elegantly point the finger. A written set of rules is easier to criticize than a federally fragmented approval practice or a project reality where new coordination meetings and construction site disruptions fall from the sky like confetti every week. Looking at the facts, a rather sad picture emerges: abolishing the HOAI would neither speed up approval processes nor eliminate the major cost drivers. The real "big points" for delays are the approval practice, excessive technical regulations, and procurement procedures, while the idea that there would suddenly be fewer legal disputes without the HOAI is an absolute illusion.

From the perspective of software providers and digitalization experts, it also becomes clear (yes, that's my area) that the real pressure in the industry comes from price wars, bureaucratic hurdles outside of the HOAI, and lack of appreciation for planning services emerges. Anyone who has experienced projects waiting for months for approvals, statements, or additional claims knows: the bottleneck is not the fee structure. The bottleneck is the question, whether a project can find a reasonable pace through the administrative system at all. And anyone who believes that digitalization alone will fix this is greatly mistaken. A digital traffic jam remains a traffic jam, just with a prettier file name and a PDF instead of a file folder. It's not the electronic shell that needs reform, but the streamlining of content requirements is crucial.

The Value of Intellectual Work: Planning is Not a Prepayment Rehearsal

Added to this is the second major misconception: the idea that a lower or completely freely negotiated fee automatically leads to cheaper, faster, or better projects. Even older analyses warned that the HOAI was originally established as a system precisely because intellectual planning services are difficult to grasp and, without a comprehensible structure, can easily lead to contractual chaos and loss of quality. This observation is more relevant today than ever. When the connection between service and remuneration becomes blurred, it is not efficiency that wins, but lack of transparency.

Unfortunately, many clients see the HOAI merely as a crude fee schedule. In doing so, they conveniently overlook that this schedule actually describes complex services: intellectual work, immense responsibility, technical depth, assumption of risk, and coordination. This is the silent tragicomedy of our industry. Good planning usually only becomes noticeable when it not works. A perfectly planned and smoothly handed-over energy and facility management concept doesn't create a big show on the construction site, but simply avoids disasters and subsequent operating costs. Communicatively, this is unfortunately about as sexy as well-maintained fire damper documentation. But hours saved in planning will inevitably be compensated on the construction site or in later building operation with multiple times the additional costs.

Furthermore, we must not forget: since the ECJ ruling of 2019 and the reform on January 1, 2021 , the HOAI is no longer binding price law of the old kind anyway. Today, it primarily serves as a system for orientation and fallback within contractual freedom. So, the HOAI is by no means the iron cage it is often portrayed as. It is a handrail. And one holds onto a handrail – sometimes out of habit, sometimes out of genuine conviction, often simply out of pure professional common sense, to avoid falling.

Service Phase 8 and the Battle for Liquidity

The debate becomes particularly absurd when one leaves the legal meta-level and delves into the operational reality of planning offices. The HOAI calculates in shares of services, partial services, and chargeable costs, but a real office lives in months, salaries, rents, software licenses (thanks again), and continuous expenses. Especially in service phase 8, site supervision, this difference sometimes gapes painfully wide.

An office doesn't pay its construction managers in "72 percent advanced site coordination," but punctually at the end of the month in Euros. If the construction period of a project, for reasons not attributable to the planner, stretches from 18 months to three years, the expenses for meetings, minutes, conflict resolution, and documentation increase massively. While time is not one-to-one identical to performance, it is the most reliable indicator of continuously arising operating costs. Therefore, flexible payment plans and construction time couplings as a supplement to the HOAI are indispensable today.

It is a fatal misconception to consider remuneration merely as reward for completed stages Planners must finance a permanent readiness to perform The presence on the construction site and the responsiveness to unforeseen disruptions cost money every single day. Anyone who thins out the planning coordination during an extended construction period for cost-saving reasons is saving precisely on problem-solving competence. It's like sending home the people with the water buckets first on a sinking ship for cost reasons.

Building Renovation: Where the System Reaches Its Limits

The imbalance becomes even more dramatic when we move away from new construction and turn to building in existing structures – the absolute megatrend of our time. The HOAI structure is historically strongly oriented towards new buildings and often no longer adequately addresses the highly complex, fragmented, and often unpredictable requirements requirements of renovation, revitalization, and monument protection. There is a lack of sufficient consideration for existing building fabric, the fixation on cost calculation is problematic, and the surcharges for repairs are often too low.

From my own experience in dealing with existing buildings, I can only underline this: Anyone working with existing buildings is constantly working with surprises. Hidden pollutants, damaged structures, incomplete as-built documentation from the 80s – this is the daily reality. A tiny structural measure can trigger enormous investigation and coordination work. The preservation of a historic facade element or the fire safety upgrade of an old utility shaft brings hardly any chargeable costs (aka "new construction volume") with it, but requires a massive amount of intellectual effort, expertise, and possibly even risk-taking. A fee system that rigidly adheres to construction costs simply does not fairly reflect this intellectual and planning effort.

New construction ticks according to plan; existing buildings tick according to findings.

The HOAI Amendment 2026: Sustainability, BIM, and Fair Fee Schedules

So what to do? The answer is not abolition, but modernization. This is precisely the core of the current reform debates, which are working towards an HOAI amendment in 2026. There are a multitude of immediately implementable simplification proposals that would retain the HOAI as a working tool but make it more practical. Three crucial areas of action are emerging: sustainability, digitalization (BIM), and the adjustment of outdated fee schedules.

Firstly, the topic of sustainability must be fundamentally integrated. Resource conservation, lifecycle considerations, and climate protection are no longer exotic special requests today, but the foundation of any planning. Expert opinions suggest finally including sustainability as a regular planning objective in basic services, while specific certifications (such as DGNB or LEED) remain as special services.

Secondly, work on existing buildings must be upgraded. Although experts do not expect a completely independent service category for 'existing buildings' – the HOAI will likely remain focused on new construction, like it or not – regulations regarding existing building fabric to be incorporated and surcharges for renovations are to be revised. There are concrete considerations for simplified calculation factors or flat-rate increases that will finally compensate realistically for the additional effort involved in renovations.

Thirdly: Building Information Modeling (BIM). Anyone planning and building today knows that the digital twin is the key to efficient subsequent building operation (CAFM). However, BIM has often been a gray area in terms of fees. A method-neutral clarification of the service descriptions and a newly defined 'standard BIM process' as an annex to the HOAI are intended to provide clarity here. The digital planning method is no longer a pipe dream, but hard reality. If services are recorded more systematically, architects and engineers can also finally bill fairly for the enormous data development, , which later benefits facility management and thus lower operating costs, which later benefits facility management and thus lower operating costs

Fourth, we cannot avoid the fee schedules themselves. The table values have not been adjusted since 2013. They completely ignore years of price increases, exploding personnel and software costs, as well as the massively increased planning effort due to new standards. A framework inevitably loses its acceptance if it financially pretends that we are still living in 2013. Significant increases, especially for smaller project sizes, are therefore essential.

Outlook: The Planning Industry of the Coming Years

If I bundle these developments, I see not a radical revolution in the coming years, but a phase of tough but absolutely necessary shifts. The HOAI will not die. It will continue to move away from dogmatic price law and transform into a hopefully highly relevant (sic!) structural and quality instrument.

At the same time, the industry itself will have to move. Planners and engineers must articulate the value of their own services much more clearly and defend them more confidently. Describing oneself as performing sophisticated, intellectual work is not a rhetorical luxury, but a pure survival strategy. Those who cannot communicate their own value will be mercilessly degraded by the market to an arbitrarily reducible cost item. And who would know this better than the countless engineering firms in self-exploitation mode ("No, why, 60 hours a week for my husband and me is normal?".

The HOAI is the unloved problem child that should be put out on the street and it is a proven, albeit aged, tool. Some want to throw the construct away out of frustration, others polish it out of pure nostalgia. Both are wrong. We need to take this tool apart, sharpen the dull blades, scrape off the rust regarding existing buildings, and equip it with digital interfaces for BIM and sustainability. Because existing buildings and their management count.

And if this actually succeeds with the 2026 amendment, we will end up with a system that does justice to the reality on construction sites and in planning offices again.

And if not?

Then in five years, we will be having exactly the same debate – just with new buzzwords and even fewer skilled workers willing to put up with this madness.

I'm out then, anyway.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating / 5. Vote count:

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

We are sorry that this post was not useful for you!

Let us improve this post!

Tell us how we can improve this post?

Scroll to Top